Is Jonathan India Broken?

Dylan Buell/Getty Images

Is Jonathan India Broken?


Is Jonathan India Broken?


Dylan Buell/Getty Images

Last week, I wrote about Hunter Greene and Nick Lodolo as reasons for optimism in Cincinnati. On the heels of one of the worst seasons in franchise history, I’m here to give the fans more reasons to smile. Smiles don’t win pennants, but they do give hope and a desire to support the team. 

162 games is a very long season, and this team has been buried in the cellar for the better part of the last decade. There are more bright spots on this roster than you think. Don’t believe me? Check this out. 

Has there ever been a more quickly forgotten Rookie of the Year than Jonathan India? Not only did he win the 2021 Rookie of the Year, he almost won it unanimously (29 of 30 votes). 

In 2021, India was fantastic. He hit .269 with 21 home runs, 69 RBIs, 98 runs (18th), and 12 stolen bases (36th). He also had a walk rate of over 11%, which was top 30 among all qualified hitters. 

Fast forward to 2022, and India saw injuries derail all the momentum he gained in his rookie season. He played just 103 games and never seemed to be completely healthy. His stats took a big dip as well. He posted a .249 average with 10 home runs, 41 RBIs, 48 runs, and three stolen bases. 

Let’s fast-forward to early 2023. Should Reds fans be concerned with India, or will he return to his 2021 form? Time to dig deep on this one. Grab a shovel.

There were a few significant dips in his production. Let’s take a look at what happened and why. 

His batting average dropped 20 points, while his BABIP (batting average on balls in play) dropped from .326 to .305. He experienced a dip in his Hard Hit rate, which dipped from 34.1% down to 25.7%. Does that concern me? No. Here’s why. 

There are a few essential advanced statistics to look into when I am analyzing a player’s performance. 

India’s line drive rate actually went UP from 22.5% to 22.7% (good sign). His hitting to the opposite field actually improved as well, going from 17.4% to 20.9%. 

India didn’t hit the ball quite as hard in 2022, but I’m not convinced he was completely healthy for more than a few games in the season. His walk rate took a dip from 11.3% to 7.4%, which may be concerning except for one thing. 

He still wasn’t chasing bad pitches. His discipline at the plate isn’t quite elite, but it is solid. He was 56th out of 205 hitters (400+ plate appearances) with a 27.9% chase rate on pitches outside the zone. Putting that in perspective, he was above the likes of Ronald Acuna, Kyle Tucker, Carlos Correa, Freddie Freeman, and more. In 2021? He was 21st out of 188 qualified hitters (that IS elite). 

India has shown himself to be a solid hitter who doesn’t beat himself. 2022 can be chalked up to a player who was constantly dealing with injury throughout the season. He is still a solid hitter, great baserunner, and will be batting near the top of the order for a long time to come. 

This is the second of many in a series to get the Cincinnati fan base hyped about the future. We are fans of the first professional team in all of baseball. Bright days are ahead, and India is one of the bright spots. Don’t lose faith, hope, or anything in between. This team has talent from the Major League roster all the way down to rookie ball. 

Cincinnati Reds baseball is coming back in a big way. Stay tuned. 


More The Wright Way Network